Am I in Over My Head as an Ally as My Friend Fights for Purity?

We can ask this question as an expression of humility or fear. Before we examine factors that indicate that your friend may need additional help (more than you as an ally), let’s consider each potential motive for asking this question.

Why We Might Think We’re in Over Our Head

First, there is humility in this question. In effect, this questions says, “I am willing to be your friend and I won’t allow the awkwardness of talking about pornography to interfere with our friendship. But if you need more than my friendship in the pursuit of purity, I won’t be offended and personalize that as if I failed.” That demeanor is an essential quality in a good ally.

Second, there can be fear in this question. Too often this question can say, “If more than my friendship is needed, then I’m not sure I want to be involved. This sounds complicated.” This is a disposition that magnifies the sense of stigma and shame that are already very prevalent with sexual sin.

From these first two points, we want to (a) learn to ask a good question for the right reason, and (b) implement a wise answer to a good question.

4 Signs Your Friend Needs a Larger Care Team

In the remainder of this article, we want to consider four questions, each of which would point towards a different type of person who should be added to your friend’s care team. If multiple questions get a “yes” answer, then it would be advisable to add multiple people to your friend’s care team.

1. Is the sexual sin illegal?

All sin is immoral. Some sin is illegal. Illegal sin does not require a double dose of redemption to be forgiven. But when sin is illegal it does mean that a second jurisdiction should be involved. When sin is illegal, the redemptive community of the church should be involved AND the God-appointed (Romans 13:1-6) civil authorities should also be involved.

To state it plainly, when the safety of children is involved, friends do call the cops on their friends. Safety is the first and foremost concern in any helping relationship.

If you want additional guidance on when and how to involve the civil authorities, I would highly recommend the “Becoming a Church that Cares Well for the Abused” curriculum at

2. Am I being asked to keep harmful secrets?

Here, we are specifically speaking to situations where your friend is married and whether what your friend is confiding to you should also be known by his/her spouse. This would include actions that mean your friend’s spouse is beginning to build a false sense of trust (i.e., trust that is not warranted by your friend’s level of purity). This might include infidelity, spending family income without his/her spouse’s awareness, or repeated failure with pornography.

If your friend is married, an early conversation when you agree to be an ally should be, “What frequency or depth of relapse does your spouse want to be informed about?” Your friend’s spouse is trusting you to serve as a filter of information for them. You need to know the spouse’s answer to this question to honor that trust. Possible answers to this question might be:

  • The spouse wants to know about every lapse.
  • The spouse wants to know about any lapse that is not voluntarily confided and responded to appropriately.
  • The spouse wants to know about any lapse that crosses a particular threshold.

The “right” answer to this question is the answer that your friend’s spouse believes best helps them at this level of marital restoration.

3. Is the frequency, duration, and depth of my friend’s sexual activity getting worse?

This is the question that helps us identify if we are contributing to a remedy or enabling the problem. When your role in your friend’s life is not resulting in the frequency, duration, or depth of your friends sexual sin decreasing that is a sign that he/she needs more than a friend.

Your friendship is still a vital part of the solution. But increases in these three dimensions mean that a counselor should also be involved. In these instances, you might say something like this:

“You trusted me enough to ask me to be an ally. That took courage. As I’ve served in that role, things have gotten worse. That doesn’t mean we’ve failed. It means additional help is needed. I’m asking that you reach out to a counselor, so that my role as your ally can be more effective.”

4. Is my friend growing indifferent towards their sin?

This is where we begin to discuss church discipline. Church discipline is not primarily about the size of a sin, but one’s attitude toward their sin. When your friend said they wanted help that was an indicator that he/she was repentant. However, if your friend is beginning to grow indifferent towards his/her sin, then the church has a warning role to play.

Church discipline is not about kicking people out of the church any more than parental discipline is about disowning a child. It is about restoring and shaping character. If your church needs guidance on how to conduct church discipline in a restorative and holistic manner, here is guidance.

In summary, it is good to be humble enough to realize that your friend may need more than an ally. This article gives you four questions to ask as you serve as an ally in order to determine who else may need to be involved in your friend’s pursuit of purity.